Who’s been more dominant: Clemson or Bama?

A quick look at Clemson and Alabama shows just how good both teams have been. They’re both 10-0. Clemson’s average margin of victory is 33 points. Bama’s is 35. Both have faced a few decent teams and a few not-so-good ones. So, who’s been better?

One way to check is to use relative performance, which sounds more complex than it really is.

The premise is simple: How did a team perform relative to how other teams perform against the same competition. So, for example, Alabama averaged 7.17 yards per play vs. Ole Miss this year. Is that good? Well, Ole Miss’s defense is allowing 6.28 yards/play to all other FBS teams it’s played this year, so Alabama was 14.2 percent better than average against the Rebels.

We can do this for every team both Clemson and Alabama have played and come to some conclusions. To do this, we picked two basic stats: Points per drive and yards per play. We looked at those numbers for both offense and defense.

First, let’s compare the defenses.

Screen Shot 2018-11-11 at 9.30.25 PMScreen Shot 2018-11-11 at 9.30.44 PM

The blue lines above represent opponent performance against all other FBS teams, while the red lines represent performance vs. Clemson and Alabama, respectively.

Alabama’s defense has been a bit more up-and-down, but is peaking now, it would appear. Clemson’s defense was essentially average against Texas A&M, but has been excellent ever since.

Now a look at the offense.

Screen Shot 2018-11-11 at 9.40.46 PMScreen Shot 2018-11-11 at 9.40.57 PM

Clemson’s offense has been a bit erratic, with some huge games and some average ones, but not dramatically below average. The early QB issues help explain some of this, but it’s worth nothing that BC did a really nice job against the Tigers.

Alabama, on the other hand, was dominant offensively pretty much all season, but Mississippi State did do a nice job of containing the Tide. Is that because Tua is nursing an injury? Because Mississippi State’s defensive front is insanely good? TBD.

Anyway, on the whole, here’s how things shape up in order of percent change from opponent averages…

Screen Shot 2018-11-11 at 9.30.53 PM

Long story short, Clemson appears to have a legitimate edge on defense, and Alabama has a real edge — particularly in scoring — on offense.

Of course, the interesting part of this is, Trevor Lawrence figures to get better, and so does the Clemson offense. Meanwhile, Alabama’s defense has pitched back-to-back shutouts, albeit against bad offenses. So perhaps that Tide D is also making strides.

The long and short of it is, these are clearly dominant teams, and their relative dominance only serves to further illustrate that we should be getting a ridiculous playoff matchup in a few months.

Week 11 picks with Damien Woody

Screen Shot 2018-11-08 at 2.04.50 PM

College Game Day is coming to Chestnut Hill this week, which isn’t a sentence we planned on typing this season. It’s a huge game between No. 17 Boston College and No. 2 Clemson, and so we needed a huge guest picker for the week. Enter BC great Damien Woody.

Q. So, this game is getting plenty of attention, but does BC have a real chance at pulling the upset?

A. I think BC has a shot. Now, Clemson is uber talented. As far as pro prospects, they’ve got guys littered all across the field, particularly on defense. But they’ve got a true freshman quarterback, and you never know what you’re going to get from a guy who’s basically coming out of high school. The game’s in Boston. It’s going to be cold. A team from down south, playing in cold weather, you never know how they’ll react. Does BC have a shot? Yeah, absolutely. You’ve got A.J. Dillon, one of the best running backs in the nation. Anthony Brown is playing pretty well. Good offensive line. Defense is good. Yeah, I absolutely think BC has a shot to win the game.

Q. For all the justified attention on A.J. Dillon, that offensive line for BC has done a lot of the dirty work. What do you make of that group going up against this terrific Clemson defense?

A. Clemson is bringing like four first-round picks on the defensive line. But when I think about the BC offensive line, I think about last year, when there were a bunch of injuries and a lot of young guys had to play. There were growing pains. But now, some of those growing pains are paying dividends because those guys all have experience. This is strength on strength when you look at both of these teams. I’m looking forward to that matchup.

Q. Anthony Brown’s skill set is a lot like Kellen Mond at Texas A&M, and Mond had some success against Clemson. What’s Brown have to do in this game to have the same type of success?

A. No. 1, with any quarterback, you have to take care of the football. With a team as talented as Clemson, don’t give them anything cheap. No. 2, he has to utilize his legs. Get him on the edges. Play-action. Do things — don’t have him just sitting in the pocket because that’s where that defensive line can present some problems. Get him on the move and play-action off A.J. Dillon, you might be able to expose some things in the intermediate and deeper part of the field.

Q. What’s a game like this at BC mean in the big picture for the program? It’s been a long time since they’ve had a game with this much magnitude on the national stage.

A. I felt coming into the season, BC had potential to have a pretty good season. With A.J. Dillon missing the game against NC State, I believe that was pivotal in losing that game. But being 7-2, being ranked 17 in one poll and 14 in another, going against the No. 2 team at night, College Game Day, the fact that BC built new facilities — you see the momentum that BC has been building. I’m telling you, it’s going to be a lot of excitement, a lot of fun in Chestnut Hill, and if BC can pull this off somehow, boy, that’s exposure for a program in a part of the country not many people look at as playing big-time football.

Q. On the flip side, what’s your thoughts on Clemson and how they might stack up against Alabama in the long run?

A. Athlete for athlete, they match up. Dabo Swinney has done a tremendous job of building up that program and every year, those two teams are going at it for the national championship. So, there’s nothing different this year. I think the reason they brought in Trevor Lawrence and put him in the starting lineup was in preparation for Alabama. Now, hopefully BC will have something to say about that this weekend, but you have to give Clemson a lot of credit. They’ve recruited well, they’re very well coached, they’ve got a lot of athletes. They’re a strong football team.

Screen Shot 2018-11-08 at 1.59.58 PM

Week 10 ACC picks with Ahmad Hawkins

Screen Shot 2018-10-31 at 4.03.23 PM

Virginia could be on the cusp of a Coastal Division title, and that’s a big surprise to most ACC fans. One person who’s not as shocked by the Hoos’ run is Ahmad Hawkins, a UVA legend — he caught the game winner the last time the Cavaliers won in Blacksburg — and a current analyst for the team. We checked in to get some insight on this year’s Hoos.

Q. Virginia is 6-2 and most folks are pretty surprised. Could you see this coming?

A. You could see some of it coming, but the thing that’s surprised me the most is how we’ve adjusted our defensive scheme due to the injuries and the lack of pass rush. They used the bye week to form some new schemes to help alleviate the need to get to the passer as much and help the secondary perform better. We knew that was our strength.

Q. Bryce Perkins isn’t putting up numbers like Tua, but it seems like he’s really transformed the Virginia offense with his athleticism. What’s been the impact from your viewpoint?

A. Just having a quarterback that’s mobile. That’s something Coach Bronco has wanted from Day 1. They inherited Kurt Benkert, who was more of the classic pro-style quarterback, and he’s with the Atlanta Falcons now. He had a live arm, but he didn’t move like a Taysom Hill type. When they brought Bryce in, I knew he’d help overshadow some of the deficiencies we had on the offensive line and allow that group to actually gel and scheme for those inside zone-reads. And his ability to use his legs really occupies those linebackers and doesn’t let them get a beat on what we do offensively. He’s not going to wow anyone with his passing numbers, but the one thing in college football that’s so scary is having that dynamic quarterback that can run with the football.

Q. I love chatting with Bronco Mendenhall because he’s unlike any other coach out there. He’s thoughtful about so many things most coaches probably take for granted. What’s been your experience dealing with him?

A. Coach is very thoughtful. He’s very strategic even when you’re having a good time with him. One thing is, he wants to make sure the energy he puts out is genuine and positive and he understands that people hang on every word you say, and he doesn’t want to say anything out o character. He’s a lot of fun to be around, and I said when he got hired, he’s the type of coach you run through a wall for.

Q. I don’t feel like Virginia is playing the “Nobody believes in us” card so much as they just really believe in themselves. Fair assessment?

A. Oh yeah. It’s basically the “if you build it, they will come” mantra. They understand our fan base hasn’t viewed a consistent winner. So you can’t complain about fans if you’re not putting out a great product. Last year, we got to six wins, but the product wasn’t as attractive. Now, the product fits what you see with the record. We’re 6-2, but this team is also fun to watch. And the fans have been there, but we want to get them to come to the stadium, too.

Q. What does UVA have to do to beat Pitt on Friday?

A. It’s going to be tough physically because Pitt comes right at you. They’re going to hit you in the mouth, they’re going to pull guards. It’s power football. When they take a shot in the passing game, it’s off of play-action. So that’ll test our defensive front and our linebackers to be very disciplined and understand that all that weight lifting and conditioning you did is going to come in during this game. We’ve played some finesse teams, and now we’re going to see the run-it-down-your-throat team. It’s going to test our fortitude.

Screen Shot 2018-10-31 at 4.01.42 PM

Week 9 ACC picks with Jeff Cameron

Screen Shot 2018-10-25 at 1.33.56 PMThis is a picture of Jeff we found via Google Image search.
It’s the best picture we could find. The next best one was of Corey Clark.

OK, so what if Clemson-Florida State isn’t the signature game of the season that it used to be. It’s still a matchup of quite possibly the two most talented rosters in the ACC, and plenty of these guys will be suiting up on Sundays soon enough. Plus, FSU has been playing better of late, so we checked in with our pal Jeff Cameron of ESPN Tallahassee to talk about where the Seminoles stand and if they’ve got a shot of pulling the upset.

Q. Last year’s team obviously had it’s on-field issues but seemed as much as anything a failure of culture. This year, the personnel problems are obvious, but how would you say Willie has managed the locker room?

A. Coach Taggart inherited both personnel issues and a fractured locker room upon his arrival in Tallahassee. It’s a lot to overcome in a Coach’s first season but if there is an area that has improved appreciably it is within the culture of the program. When you speak with Coach Taggart it is apparent that this is an aspect of program building that Willie takes very seriously and has largely succeeded in fostering during his first season.

Q. The FSU D-line is really good, but the comparisons to Clemson’s unit seem a bit overstated to me. What’s your take?

A. Marvin Wilson would not start for Clemson right now. Marvin Wilson will likely be a first-round pick in future. Brian Burns might start for Clemson but there isn’t another guy on FSU’s front that would. Clemson has an embarrassment of riches along the defensive line that is rightly the envy of every team in the ACC and moreover, the country.

Q. We’ve talked about the timeline of turning around an offensive line. What’s the bigger picture timeline for Willie? Does it feel like each year you’re not catching up to Clemson, you’re falling behind?

A. Things change quickly in college football because you only get kids for four years.

Q. You can bring on any four people for a radio show, dead or alive. Who you interviewing?

A. Isaac Newton, Jane Goodall, Edward S. Curtis, James Baldwin, (Bonus: Eunice Kennedy Shriver)

Q. Does FSU stand a chance, and if so, what has to happen?

A. They have a chance. Not a great chance mind you but if the defensive line can neutralize Clemson’s running game and force a Freshman QB to beat them on the road who knows how he’ll respond? Trevor Lawrence is obviously a special player but if it’s close in the second half all of the pressure is on Clemson and perhaps the weight of that causes Freshman mistakes. At the end of the day, FSU will need help in the way of turnovers and big plays on special teams to pull off the upset as I just can’t envision the offense being able to block Clemson consistently enough to sustain drives.

Our picks…

Screen Shot 2018-10-25 at 1.31.29 PM

Week 8 Tiered Rankings: Who is “somebody”?

We’re at an interesting inflection point of the college football season, when records start to look substantial, but still come with the universal qualifier of “they ain’t played nobody.”

I find a pretty good way of weeding out that argument is to look at records vs. teams that should count as “somebody,” and that starts with a firm definition. For now, we’re using this: The top 40 in S&P+ along with any other Power 5 programs that have 2 or fewer losses and Group of Five teams with 1 or fewer losses.

That list ends up including 51 teams, which is probably a little more than we’d like, but it’s a good starting point that ensures we’re not ignoring anyone. More importantly, it’s a precise definition. Fans tend to think anyone other than Alabama is nobody, which makes for an impossible standard. Teams don’t set their own schedules, and they don’t control how other teams perform against other opposition, so using a lofty strength of schedule bar essentially eliminates everyone. Instead, we’re setting a reasonable bar that, over the course of a 12-game season, tends to even out.

So, if that’s our list of “somebodies,” how do teams stack up?

By record, we’d start with Clemson. The Tigers are 4-0 against somebodies (A&M, Georgia Southern, Syracuse & NC State) with an average margin of victory of 18 points. Now, we know what you’re saying. Those aren’t “somebody.” And to be sure, we can have degrees of Somebody-ness. But by our definition we started with, yes, those are all somebodies.

The only other team with four wins over somebody is LSU. The Tigers are 4-1 with wins over Miami, Auburn, Mississippi State and Georgia. It’s a strong resume, even if the underlying numbers — 15th in S&P+, 19th in offensive efficiency — aren’t exactly stellar. Being elite at one thing and decent at all the others is enough to be pretty darn good.

At the other end of the spectrum, there’s Arizona State. The Sun Devils have four losses this year, all by 7 points, and all against “somebodies.” Perhaps we’re underestimating the work Herm Edwards has done so far.

The same is (sort of) true for Nebraska and UCLA. No, Scott Frost and Chip Kelly have not righted the ship in Year 1, but they’ve also combined for nine losses to “somebodies.” Granted, those games haven’t been particularly close, but as we evaluate their performances during the debut season growing pains, it’s worth a reminder that they’ve not exactly had it easy.

But what perhaps stands out the most is this: Even casting a pretty wide net in defining our “somebodies,” there are only 17 teams that have multiple wins against that group. That’s it. Of 130 FBS teams, only 17 have two ore more wins vs. the 51 teams that can make a case for being kind-of, sort-of good, and it’s a list with plenty of surprising names. So maybe most teams really ain’t played nobody.

Anyway, here’s the list of multi-win teams:
Clemson, 4-0
LSU, 4-1
Notre Dame, 3-0
Texas Tech, 2-1
Iowa State, 2-2
Virginia, 2-1
NC State, 2-1
Alabama, 2-0
Florida, 2-1
Kentucky, 2-1
USC, 2-3
Washington State, 2-0
Michigan, 2-1
Washington, 2-2
Purdue, 2-1
Missouri, 2-2
Stanford, 2-2

Names you don’t see here: Texas, West Virginia, Michigan, Georgia, Iowa, Ohio State, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, Penn State, UCF, Texas A&M, Miami. All have one or zero wins over our Group of 51.

Again, that doesn’t mean they aren’t good teams. It’s critical to remember that strength of schedule is an independent variable that measures our level of confidence in a team’s quality, not the underlying level of quality. If Alabama played Kent State 12 straight times, it wouldn’t make the Tide any better or worse. It would just mean we didn’t have much data to tell us how good they were. Instead, what we can say from this exercise is that Clemson, despite protests about its weak schedule, actually HAS played somebody, and done quite well. So have LSU and Notre Dame. And while that doesn’t mean those teams won’t lose moving forward, it offers us some evidence that those losses won’t be due to a lack of ability to beat good teams.

This week’s tiered rankings, using the above data points:

Tier 1: Elite (2)

Alabama, Clemson

I wrote a little on the inevitability of Tide-Tigers Part IV last night (and yes, I’m now kicking myself that Fredo is actually the OLDER brother. I’ve killed too many brain cells with whiskey.)

Tier 2: Knocking on the door (12)

Notre Dame, LSU, Oklahoma, Michigan, Georgia, Washington, Ohio State, UCF, Florida, Iowa, Kentucky, Texas

Tier 3: Pretty, pretty good (11)

App State, Fresno State, Penn State, Wisconsin, A&M, Utah, West Virginia, Washington State, Purdue, Houston, USF

Tier 4: Resume builders (22)

Miami, Auburn, Mississippi State, Oklahoma State, Utah State, Texas Tech, Cincinnati, North Texas, NC State, Duke, Temple, Iowa State, Oregon, Michigan State, Stanford, Boston College, Virginia Tech, Syracuse, Michigan State, USC, San Diego State, Arizona State

NC State, App State & Bama reads

Few quick reads for you on a Thursday…

Week 8 ACC picks with Nate Irving

Screen Shot 2018-10-17 at 10.57.43 PM.png

This week’s guest picker is Nate Irving, an All-American in 2010 at NC State and went on to a five-year NFL career with the Broncos and Colts. We talked with Irving about this year’s Wolfpack, the impact of strength coach Dantonio Burnette, and his pick for the game against Clemson.

Q. NC State hasn’t gotten a ton of big wins yet, but they are winning more consistently now. Where do you think this program is?

A. I feel like [Dave] Doeren has gotten his guys in, a recruiting class has come through there, and [Dantonio Burnette] — we call him Thunder — he’s working wonders in the weight room. It’s paying off. It’s bringing more success for the guys on the field, and the more success there is, the more people want to come join us. I think with Doeren, he’s been able to stick around, get his guys in, coach them up and that’s starting to pay dividends.

Q. What would a win over Clemson mean for NC State?

A. Against this team, it’s very big. The last couple games, it’s been close. Being ranked, going against another ranked opponent — it’s a good test. And it’s a rivalry, whether they want to say so or not. Textile Bowl. It’s going to be a great game.

Q. What do you think of how the defense has performed after losing so many big names?

A. I think they’re playing good. It’s opportunities for guys to make a name for themselves after a lot of guys left. Germaine Pratt, I’ve been really impressed with what he’s been doing. We’re inexperienced, but the games we’ve played, it’s been experience. But this game will be what tells us where we are and where we need to be.

Q. When you talk about coaches being given time, to me that’s about building a sustainable culture that lasts beyond one class of great players. Is that sort of what we’re seeing happen at NC State?

A. Today’s age, we want results instantly, but every coach isn’t striking gold with every player they recruit. Things happen, injuries happen, life happens. There are things you can’t account for. Stuff you have to adjust to. It takes time. If you could just walk into a place and get the No. 1 class every year, everyone stays, everyone’s healthy — that’s one thing. But things happen. Football happens.

Q. You mentioned Coach Burnette. He seems to be at the center of so much of the Wolfpack’s success. What do you think of the job he’s done?

A. Man, I’ll send Thunder a message every now and then just to give him a hard time because when I was there, and the difference now, it’s night and day. As a former player, you’re like, damn, I wish we could’ve been a part of this. What he’s doing is great. And it’s strength and nutrition. They have a great nutrition staff. And the weight program is about lifting and power and explosion and the things that relate to football. When I was there, it was more about stretching and getting flexible. That’s good. But at the end of the day, you have to do things that relate to football.

Q. And as a guy who’s played football and had so much success, he’s not just coaching guys about how to get in shape, but like you say, it’s specific to what they’re trying to do.

A. And players notice that. He’s a guy who’s been through it and can tell you what you need to do to get there, players listen to that. But I also think he’s great at relating to the players. A lot of times, you’ll get guys from all over the place, and that’s his home. He’s home. That stands out. Guys are like, ‘He’s from here, he lives here, he went to school here, he’s part of this program. And he came back here.’

Q. OK, so I’m assuming you’re picking NC State. What’s the key for them to pull off the upset?

A. We have to do a good job in the secondary, but the defense has to play big. They run the ball really well, and if they get to running the ball on us, we can be in trouble. But if we can get off on third down, create a couple turnovers, we’ll be OK.

Screen Shot 2018-10-17 at 10.39.58 PM